Gears of War 3 panelists torn on Carmine's fate, talk film adaptation

Comic-Con 2010: Cliff Bleszinski and Ron Fergusson debate whether the COG squad member should live or die and offer the latest on the Gears movie.

Who Was There:The panel initially consisted of Gears of War 3 design director Cliff Bleszinski and executive producer Ron Fergusson, but they were later joined by Gears universe author Karen Traviss and voice actors Carlos Ferro (Dominic), Lester Speight (The Cole train), and Michael Gough (Carmine).

What They Talked About: Bleszinski and Fergusson kicked off the panel by discussing where they were at in terms of development for the game. With the release date set for April 2011, Fergusson said that everything was coming together nicely and that the team was focused on four pillars: campaign, Horde mode, Beast mode, and competitive multiplayer.

Each mode has been designed carefully, and the two men explained that Beast mode is not meant to be a "reverse Horde mode" but a mode that is class based. Playing a Ticker is entirely different from playing a Berserker, so depending on individual play styles, gamers can pick which enemy type represents them best.

The Gears of War series was always meant to be a cooperative experience and never meant to feel tacked on, they said. Having four player co-op has its own challenges in terms of storytelling, as the story is now witnessed by three other people. As a result, the only way to see a character's specific story is to play as him or her.

On the subject of co-op, split-screen co-op for the campaign, as well as Horde mode and Beast mode, will be available. But four-player split-screen would be too technically challenging and will likely not happen.

When asked why female squad members were included, Fergusson said that he was surprised at how many women were fans of the series and that he wanted to represent them as well. Bleszinski said he knew there were a lot of girl gamers out there and wanted them to taken seriously.

The demo during the panel featured the video that was shown at E3, which can be viewed here. More details of what went on in that demo can be found in GameSpot's E3 preview.

At E3, the voice actor for Jace Stratton was announced to be Drake, a Canadian artist and actor who has worked with such performers as Kanye West and Eminem. Claudia Black has also joined the cast and will be the voice of Samantha Byrne.

For more Gears lore, Traviss' Anvil Gate will be released in August and her next novel, Coalition's End, is scheduled for next March, a month before the game's release. The three books, Jacinto's Remnant, Anvil Gate, and Coalition's End, will recount what happened during the 18-month gap between Gears of War 2 and Gears of War 3.

Part of the panel was dedicated to showcasing upcoming collectable action figures, detailed busts, and weapon replicas. However, the biggest news for the franchise was Microsoft and Epic Games' recent announcement that would allow fans to influence the fate of the next Carmine recruit.

While Bleszinski and Fergusson were keen on seeing Clayton Carmine die in the most sadistic and creative way possible, Traviss and the voice actors for Cole and Dominic were interested in seeing Carmine survive this time around. Gough was torn because on the one hand, he is the voice of the character and this is directly related to potential work. But on the other hand, he said he felt that there was a Gears tradition that needs to be followed. Fergusson joked that if the results were 50-50, Baird is going to have to go.

Fans can vote online or purchase Xbox 360 avatar T-shirts to show their support for Carmine's survival or his eventual demise. T-shirts are also available at Comic-Con, and all proceeds from this campaign will go to the video game-themed charity Child's Play.

Before starting the Q&A session, Bleszinski decided to talk about the state of the Gears of War Hollywood film so that fans wouldn't have to ask. He said that the script was completed last year and what they had wouldn't be able to happen until 2012. He also said that it would cost $120 million, and the studio would be worried.

"It doesn't have a love story of Will Smith's son in it," Bleszinski joked and said that they are going with Legendary Pictures and want to have something along the lines of District 9.

Quote: "Mama Carmine is like a clown car."--Bleszinski, in reference to the fact that the voice actor for Carmine shouldn't have much to worry about in the event that the next of kin does eat it.

The Takeaway: It sounds like there are a lot of Carmine supporters, judging from the audience reaction, as well as the fans online.

Watch the highlights from the panel!

234 Comments

  • mats94

    Posted Sep 14, 2010 12:05 am GMT

    I actually think carmine should live in gears 3. the new carmine is awsome! not one of those whiny bastards in gears of war one and two

  • MAXrat320

    Posted Aug 14, 2010 7:54 pm GMT

    adam sessler!!! xplay

  • MAXrat320

    Posted Aug 14, 2010 7:53 pm GMT

    dude. carmine mus live. he should be a higher rank and have one of the other main characters die. and wtf is up with the queen who is gonna be her little b**** this time. raam and skorge died too easy. make the movie nowwww

  • jack_100

    Posted Aug 12, 2010 7:19 am GMT

    i dont know to save him or let him just die

  • ODST1175

    Posted Aug 9, 2010 12:59 am GMT

    Carmine must live!!!

  • thorleift

    Posted Jul 28, 2010 6:18 am GMT

    Let Marcus die and Carmine live...

  • KlepticGrooves

    Posted Jul 28, 2010 5:44 am GMT

    I'd rather he lived, but if he died I want him to die in some form of self-sacrifice which saves the lives of the the other characters.
    Either way I hope his part is memorable.

  • Darkbeyond

    Posted Jul 27, 2010 5:18 pm GMT

    The Carmines are awesome i want this one to live but if he dies he had better take a ton of Locust down with him

  • koospetoors

    Posted Jul 27, 2010 1:39 pm GMT

    Part of me wants him to die in the most awesomest way possible, but I also want the poor bastard's life to be spared for once, I really like the Carmine brothers.

  • ThePurpleBubble

    Posted Jul 27, 2010 1:36 pm GMT

    Anyone else think it would be epic if Clay Carmine wasn't a fresh recruit, but rather someone who is fairly up there in the ranks (above Marcus, perhaps? O.o) While, yes, it would likely end with him dying, at least it'd be with a wall of Locust corpses around him

  • lamprey263

    Posted Jul 26, 2010 5:47 pm GMT

    they should kill Carmine in every film, and in each film give him a funny story about how he escaped death but then go and kill him again and again

  • Get_Shorty

    Posted Jul 26, 2010 10:10 am GMT

    I thought Carmine should live too but I think it'll be more awsome to see how he dies.... otherwise he better live by the skin of his pants, or do into coma or paralyzation (hey he's still alive).

  • jackytheman

    Posted Jul 26, 2010 9:56 am GMT

    i want carmine lives cause u get more team mate to help u lets vote for let him LIVE!

  • Cidious84

    Posted Jul 26, 2010 1:51 am GMT

    Carmine should live !!! The previous games let the other two brothers die and Clayton should live so that his brothers would not have died in vain. Besides show the Carmine's some respect...they're risking their lives for the greater COG and human good.

  • gamefreak996

    Posted Jul 25, 2010 10:39 pm GMT

    Let carmine do something heroic dont kill him again!

  • norair

    Posted Jul 25, 2010 10:13 pm GMT

    If they want to kill Carmine they should at least let him die heroic like saving the life of Marcus or some other character

  • Mickleohb

    Posted Jul 25, 2010 7:23 pm GMT

    Aren't there 4 Carmine brothers with 2 of them still alive? So 1 could live and 1 could die. I imagine that's what they'll end up doing

  • tacoeater831

    Posted Jul 25, 2010 7:18 pm GMT

    i would like it better if we were able to choose IN game. obviously it dosent affect story that much, so why not let us wait and choose in the actual game so everyone can be happy?

  • casey_mcqueen

    Posted Jul 25, 2010 7:02 pm GMT

    I'm really glad Gears of War 3 is -already- getting this much hype this long before the release date; the only bad thing is actually waiting for it to release! I'm anxiously awaiting some fresh news about the Gears movie, and I spent a bit of time today compiling some people I think should play the COG's in a Gamespot blog post today, so check it out and let me know all of your opinions! Gears of War 3 is going to be so sweet!

  • chopsticksoup

    Posted Jul 25, 2010 5:33 pm GMT

    I want him to die. Even though both Carmines are my favorite charaters, I just think it would be cool, cuz it is Gears tradition. And I want to see how they make him die. Cliffy B said it would be with a bang.